BioEdge 263 -- Wednesday, 29 August 2007

Home   |    Archives   |    Links   |    In the media
subscribe   |    subscribe my friend   |    to the editor   |    unsubscribe
BioEdge 263: Questions over exonerated doctor

THIS WEEK


bullet 
Questions over exonerated doctor
      Nine patients died but no questions asked
bullet 
Australian stem cell trial mends hearts
      Positive results from small study
bullet 
Detective work in Phoenix uncovers assisted suicide
      Final Exit team helps woman to die
bullet 
"Why I regret donating my sperm"
      Frustrated paternity
bullet 
On-line games could become ethical laboratory
      Serious side to virtual worlds
bullet 
Savulescu proposes a change of focus for medicine
      Enhance patients to make them live longer
bullet 
California stem cell institute shaken by resignation
      Long delays cause unrest
bullet 
More US women dying in childbirth
      Experts puzzled
bullet 
China bans TV shows about cosmetic surgery
      Too coarse, says government
bullet 
China acts on gender gap
      Worst in world, says official

QUESTIONS OVER EXONERATED DOCTOR

Dr Anna Pou at a press conference The doctor who escaped being indicted for alleged involuntary euthanasia in the chaotic aftermath of Hurricane Katrina is again in the news. Dr Anna Maria Pou, a well-known head-and-neck surgeon, was arrested last year and charged with administering lethal doses of morphine and the sedative Versed to nine patients. However, in July a grand jury decided not to indict her. In a long interview with Newsweek, she explained that she had only administered drugs to give pain relief:

    "Let me tell you -- God strike me dead -- what we were trying to do was help the patients. Everything was done with their best interest in mind. First and foremost. Any medicines given were for comfort. If in doing so it hastened their deaths, then that's what happened. But, this was not, 'I'm going to go to the seventh floor and murder some people.'"

However, serious questions have emerged about the grand jury's decision. The case against Dr Pou was originally brought by Louisiana's Attorney General, Charles Foti, and five national experts in forensic medicine, palliative care and medical ethics were told to examine the facts. However, the case was inherited by District Attorney Eddie Jordan. Despite the damning conclusions reached by their study, he did not call them to testify before the grand jury. And because its deliberations are secret, it is not known whether their reports were even seen.

Prominent bioethicist Arthur Caplan, of the University of Pennsylvania, was scandalised. "In reviewing the facts and opinions, my conclusion is that the deaths of the nine persons at Memorial Medical Center in New Orleans are all cases of active euthanasia," Caplan wrote. "Each person died with massive doses of narcotic drugs in their bodies."

These could hardly have been due to a tragic medical mistake, either. "Accidental overdoses would need to have occurred nine times between 12 noon and 3:30pm, all on one floor, to every patient who was left on the floor," observed Dr John Young, former president of the American Academy of Forensic Sciences. "Again, it is noted that morphine was not ordered for seven of the patients and Versed was not ordered for any. Therefore it seems highly unlikely that nine patients died on the same floor on the same afternoon of accidental overdose."

Organised medicine, however, accepted Dr Pou's version of events unreservedly. The head of the American Medical Association, Dr Edward L. Langston, said that she and others had been "bright lights during New Orleans's darkest hour."

Although Dr Pou will not face criminal charges, she still faces several civil liability lawsuits. She is also suing the state government to reclaim her civil defence costs. ~ MSNBC, Aug 25; CNN.com, Aug 25   

AUSTRALIAN STEM CELL TRIAL CURES HEARTS

Human embryonic stem cell growing on a layer of supporting cells. A world-first clinical trial with adult stem cells has helped six patients with severe heart disease, Australian scientists claim. Doctors at a hospital in Newcastle, north of Sydney injected a rare type of adult stem cell, mesenchymal precursor cells, taken from the patients' own bone marrow, into damaged heart tissue. Afterwards they reported having fewer angina attacks, taking less medication, and having improved heart function.

The next phase of the research will involve donor tissue, as bone marrow in older patients with heart disease is "not the best", said cardiologist Suku Thambar.

Embryonic stem cells are also in the news this week for curing heart disease -- but in rats. In an article in Nature Biotechnology, scientists from the University of Washington and from the private biotechnology company Geron claim that the rats developed new heart muscle and were protected against the progression of heart failure. The study did not disclose what happened to the rats in the long term. This is a serious concern, because embryonic stem cells often form tumours with time. ~ Sydney Morning Herald, Aug 28; Seattle Times, Aug 27   

DETECTIVE WORK IN PHOENIX UNCOVERS ASSISTED SUICIDE

Arizona police may charge two members of the suicide group Final Exit with manslaughter after they helped a Phoenix woman to die in April. Jana Van Voorhis, a 58-year-old woman with a long history of mental illness, was found by her sister and brother-in-law dead in her house. They thought it was suicide, but an autopsy deemed it a natural death.

However, when they began to go through the woman's effects after the funeral, they discovered literature from the Final Exit Network, a receipt for the purchase of two helium tanks, and some mysterious messages on her answering machine. Police eventually traced the calls to a retired college professor who was an "exit guide". Under questioning he admitted that he and another guide had helped Jana die by breathing helium.

A special feature on the incident in the Phoenix newspaper New Times points out that Final Exit literature stipulates that anyone who requests its help must be mentally competent and not be opposed by close family members. However, in this case, Jana was clearly psychotic and had instructed the exit guides not to contact her family.

One of the guides told New Times that Jana was not mentally ill, but rather "in the throes of what we call existential suffering", in which "just being alive is a burden". A miserable life is reason enough for Final Exit to offer its services. It describes itself as "the only organisation in the United States willing to help individuals who are not 'terminally ill' -- six months or less to live -- hasten their deaths."

The guides also claimed that Jana had no relationship to her family, even though she regularly used to ring her sister. The two exit guides may be charged with assisted suicide, which is still a crime in Arizona. ~ New Times, Aug 23   

WHY I REGRET DONATING MY SPERM

Sperm donation continues in the news in Australia. Writing in the Australian Rationalist, Michael Linden tells of his disgust with the reproductive medicine industry which fosters "a profound cynicism with regard to our most fundamental biological relationships."

Mr Linden says that he donated sperm in 1977 and five births resulted. He recently contacted two of the children, but has resigned himself to never meeting the other three. Iit is a bitter pill for him to swallow. He writes:

    "To the parents, whether they would wish it or not, and whether they disclose to their child or not, the child will always be the donor's child. He is the father of that child. This is an inescapable biological fact and the fundamental reason why the continuing practice of donor insemination is a tragic if not a criminal mistake."

He also rejects the notion that donating sperm is as altruistic as donating any other organ. "It is not. It is to the contrary: male irresponsibility with regard to procreation conveniently elevated by the medical profession to the level of a praised social institution." ~ Australian Rationalist, Melbourne Age, Aug 27

Scottish sperm donors: Men are being offered the chance to swap their sperm for fertility treatment because of a shortage of donors in Scotland. Although a financial consideration is illegal, the Glasgow Centre for Reproductive Medicine has set up a program to allow compensation in kind. The abolition of anonymous donation appears to have led to the shortage. Demand for sperm remains high from couples where the man has fertility problems, as well as from lesbians and single women. ~ Herald, Aug 27   

ON-LINE GAMES COULD BECOME ETHICAL LABORATORY

On-line games featuring virtual worlds could become a venue for medical and sociological experiments which bypass regulations on human research subjects. Recently, education researchers at UCLA wanted to study how a disruptive event affected an on-line community. They released a virtual epidemic with a virtual disease called Whypox. It swept through an educational online site for 8 to 16-year-olds called Whyville, which supposedly has 2.7 million participants.

A more full-blooded experiment took place in the violent game World of Warcraft. A deadly virus dubbed Corrupted Blood left millions of corpses strewn over the virtual landscape. Characters fled the scene, taking the disease with them.

A recent article in the leading journal Science highlighted games' "great potential as sites for research in the social, behavioural, and economic sciences, as well as in human-centred computer science". In the past, many experiments used to be done without seeking the consent of participants, but "those days are gone," says author William Sims Bainbridge. But now scientists might be able to use on-line worlds to understand how humans react in crises.

Naturally, these environments are far from ideal for scientific surveys -- the stakes in the game are so low that participants can behave recklessly and most of them are men. However, scientists are hopeful. University of Indiana economist Edward Castronova, one of the first to study on-line games in depth, says that they could model government policies. "Down the road, you might have a situation where every government maintains a whole bunch of virtual worlds, trying out variations on its policies to see how they work." ~ Boston Globe, Aug 25; Science, Aug 27   

SAVULESCU PROPOSES A CHANGE OF FOCUS FOR MEDICINE

Modern doctors should focus less on curing the sick and more on expanding human potential for longer lifespans, says an Oxford University bioethicist. Professor Julian Savulescu told a meeting in the Australian capital, Canberra, that doctors are missing the enormous opportunities of using advances in medical science to "make happier, better people".

"If we cured all disease - cardiovascular disease, stroke, diabetes, etc. - we would only prolong life on average by 12 years," he said. "So we have pretty much reached the ceiling of what we can do by treating and preventing disease... The next frontier is enhancing life through medical intervention to make people brighter, stronger and healthier."

Dr Savulescu argues that products like caffeine and nicotine are already types of medical enhancement. "We're reaching a new stage of human development where humans will be able to not just mate and alter their genes by breeding, but also by direct intervention." The Australian-born bioethicist said that "we need a more rational approach to making better humans. This is an opportunity for Australia." ~ ABC, Aug 6; Earthtimes.org, Aug 26   

CALIFORNIA STEM CELL INSTITUTE SHAKEN BY RESIGNATION

Like Gulliver, the California Institute for Regenerative Medicine, has been pinned down by countless pygmies equipped with lawsuits. The lengthy delay in launching its ambitious US$3 billion research program, with a focus on embryonic stem cells, appears to be taking its toll. Its president, Zach Hall, resigned in April, and now its chief scientist, Arlene Chiu, has announced that she will be leaving. Several other executives have also left in recent months.   

MORE US WOMEN DYING IN CHILDBIRTH

Deaths related to childbirth amongst American women are rising -- and the experts do not know why. The numbers, though small, are inching ahead, from 12 deaths per 100,000 births in 2003 to 13 in 100,000 in 2004. Possible causes include changes in the collection of statistics, increasing obesity, older first-time mothers, and greater numbers of Caesarean sections. ~ AP, Aug 24   

CHINA BANS TV SHOWS ABOUT COSMETIC SURGERY

The Chinese government has banned TV shows about cosmetic surgery and sex changes, called them "explicit" and "cheap in tone". It has also shut down a talent show which it deemed coarse. ~ International Herald Tribune, Aug 24   

CHINA ACTS ON GENDER GAP

Responding to its increasingly skewed sex ratio, the Chinese government is drafting laws to punish parents and doctors involved in aborting females. Recently releases figures show that the eastern city of Lianyungang has the most distorted sex ratio in the country: 163.5 boys under four years of age for every 100 girls. The official Xinhua news agency says that 99 cities have gender rations higher than 125. The United Nations recommends a gender ratio of no more than 107. A Chinese official has said that his country faces the "most serious gender imbalance in the world". ~ BBC, Aug 25; Guardian, Aug 26   

  

How to support BioEdge
BioEdge and ABI's other services rely completely upon the generosity of private benefactors and volunteer workers. ABI has no institutional backing. If you would like to support the best bioethics news service on the Web, you can do it painlessly through Paymate, a thoroughly reliable payment service which is affiliated with the internet auction site eBay.

Just access the Paymate website and follow the instructions. You will need to fill in our email address, which is bioedge@australasianbioethics.org. You will also have to give your credit card details and an amount in Australian or US dollars. Thanks!

  

 

To subscribe to our weekly email newsletter,
click here for the HTML version.
click here for the text version.
To cancel your newsletter subscription, click here.

Australasian Bioethics Information
ISSN 1446-2117
Website:www.australasianbioethics.org
BioEdge editor: Michael Cook
New Zealand Contributing Editor: Carolyn Moynihan


The BioEdge privacy policy
Your subscription information will be kept private and is not publicly accessible.
Your email address and other information will never be sold to a third party or given out
without your consent. You may cancel your subscription at any time.